Verified Supermarket & Direct-to-Consumer Olive Oils

OLIVE OIL BOTTLE DATABASE

Compare 177 extra virgin olive oils sold across major US grocery stores and direct from estate producers—rated for origin transparency, olive variety chemistry, harvest freshness, and retail value.

12
Total Bottles Shown
441
Cultivar Disclosed
2
Lab Tested
Filter by Store or Online Retailer
Include Specialty & Competition Archive (496)ON
Reset
Showing 1–12 of 12 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next
Great BuyNYIOOC SilverDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
L'Intenditore Melchiorri• Italy (Umbria DOP)

L'Intenditore Melchiorri (De Medici Imports)

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100

Tasting Notes:Since the mid-1900s, in Spoleto, the Melchiorri family has preserved and taken care of the famous Moriolo cultivar. With a fruity scent and bitter and spicy notes, its roots sink into the rocky terrain of Umbria, along the hills that extend from Spoleto to Assisi. L'Intenditore is intense, fruity and full-bodied.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Moraiolo
Oleic Acid %
76.4% (O:L 9.79)
Linoleic %
7.8%
Thermal Score
91/100
ItalyHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC SilverMedium IntensityOrganicHistorical Competition Archive
IL Fiorello Moraiolo• United States

IL Fiorello Moraiolo

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA87/100

Tasting Notes:A beautiful olive oil of the Moraiolo variety, IL Fiorello Moraiolo is buttery with the aroma and taste of ripe fruit.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Moraiolo
Oleic Acid %
76.4% (O:L 9.79)
Linoleic %
7.8%
Thermal Score
91/100
United StatesHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Sibi Lucia• Italy (Umbria DOP)

Sibi Lucia - Umbria Tellus

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA85/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Moraiolo
Oleic Acid %
76.4% (O:L 9.79)
Linoleic %
7.8%
Thermal Score
91/100
ItalyHarvest: 2023
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedRobust Intensity
$57.90/L
McEvoy Ranch• United States (California (Petaluma))

Cooking Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 85% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$28.95 (500 mL · $57.90/L) at McEvoy Ranch DirectMcEvoy Ranch Direct
Verified 2026-11-04
Cultivar: Not Listed Online (Check Bottle)
United StatesDark GlassHarvest: 2025
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$77.20/L
McEvoy Ranch• United States (California (Petaluma))

Stripes Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 85% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$28.95 (375 mL · $77.20/L) at McEvoy Ranch DirectMcEvoy Ranch Direct
Verified 2026-11-04
Cultivar: Not Listed Online (Check Bottle)
United StatesTin CanHarvest: 2025
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$106.53/L
McEvoy Ranch• United States (California (Petaluma))

Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 85% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$39.95 (375 mL · $106.53/L) at McEvoy Ranch DirectMcEvoy Ranch Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:Fresh green aromas of cut grass and artichoke lead into notes of ripe banana.

Cultivar: Not Listed Online (Check Bottle)
United StatesDark GlassHarvest: 2025
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$66.67/L
McEvoy Ranch• United States (California (Petaluma))

Organic Olio Nuovo Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 85% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$50.00 (750 mL · $66.67/L) at McEvoy Ranch DirectMcEvoy Ranch Direct
Verified 2026-11-04
Cultivar: Not Listed Online (Check Bottle)
United StatesDark GlassHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$146.67/L
McEvoy Ranch• United States (California (Petaluma))

Organic Limited Edition Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$55.00 (375 mL · $146.67/L) at McEvoy Ranch DirectMcEvoy Ranch Direct
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
MoraioloHigh
Oleic Acid %
76.4% (O:L 9.79)
Linoleic %
7.8%
Thermal Score
91/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark GlassHarvest: 2025
Inspect Record
Top PickMedium IntensityOrganic
$73.01/L
Badia a Coltibuono• Italy (Tuscany (Chianti))

a Coltibuono Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+93/100
Available Stores:Whole Foods
$36.49 (500 mL · $73.01/L) at Whole FoodsWhole Foods
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio, Leccino, MoraioloHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.5% (O:L 10.2)
Linoleic %
7.4%
Thermal Score
90/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Great BuyMedium IntensityOrganic
$38.86/L
Lucini Italia• Italy (Tuscany / Central Italy)

Organic Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 75% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Available Stores:Whole Foods
$19.42 (500 mL · $38.86/L) at Whole FoodsWhole Foods
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio, Moraiolo, LeccinoHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Great BuyMedium Intensity
$42.44/L
Lucini Italia• Italy (Tuscany / Central Italy)

Premium Select Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 75% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Sold at 2 stores (Wegmans, Whole Foods)
Available Stores:WegmansWhole Foods
$31.88 (751 mL · $42.44/L) at Whole FoodsWhole Foods
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio, Moraiolo, LeccinoHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Great BuyMedium Intensity
$14.99/L
Lucini Italia• Italy (Tuscany / Central Italy)

Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 75% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA85/100
Sold at 3 stores (Walmart, Wegmans, Whole Foods)
Available Stores:WalmartWegmansWhole Foods
$14.98 (1000 mL · $14.99/L) at WalmartWalmart
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio, Moraiolo, LeccinoHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Showing 1–12 of 12 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next