Verified Supermarket & Direct-to-Consumer Olive Oils

OLIVE OIL BOTTLE DATABASE

Compare 177 extra virgin olive oils sold across major US grocery stores and direct from estate producers—rated for origin transparency, olive variety chemistry, harvest freshness, and retail value.

13
Total Bottles Shown
441
Cultivar Disclosed
2
Lab Tested
Filter by Store or Online Retailer
Include Specialty & Competition Archive (496)ON
Reset
Showing 1–13 of 13 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next
Great BuyNYIOOC SilverDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Black Selection Melchiorri• Italy (Umbria DOP)

Black Selection Melchiorri (Olio Melchiorri)

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100

Tasting Notes:This is our new selection oil, with which my grandfather started his business more than 60 years ago. It is also the oil for which we are most known and recognized. Moraiolo, Frantoio, Leccino and Melchiorri olives are harvested from the rocky ground of Umbria along the foothills extending from Spoleto to Assisi. Intense, fruity and full-bodied, the oil features the fragrances and flavors of the enchanting land of Umbria.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
ItalyHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyDOP CertifiedHistorical Competition Archive
De Cecco• Italy (Val di Mazara DOP)

Olio Extravergine Di Oliva Regione Sicilia Val Di Mazara DOP

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Sold at 3 stores (Amazon, Walmart, Wegmans)
Available Stores:AmazonWalmartWegmans
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Aitana
Great BuyIGP CertifiedHistorical Competition Archive
Frantoio Franci• Italy (Toscano IGP)

Olio Toscano Frantoio Franci

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Frantoio Melchiorri• Italy (Umbria DOP)

Frantoio Melchiorri (Olio Melchiorri)

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100

Tasting Notes:Frantoio Melchiorri is a new natural choice, not filtered, with respect for traditional techniques and contemporary flavors. It has a unique, original and straightforward profile with a balanced aroma. Our olives come from the rocky ground of Umbria along the foothills extending from Spoleto to Assisi. The EVOO is medium-intense, fruity and full-bodied, with fragrances and flavors of the enchanting land of Umbria.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
ItalyHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC SilverDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Frutto dell'Olivo Melchiorri• Italy (Umbria DOP)

Frutto dell'Olivo Melchiorri (Olio Melchiorri)

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100

Tasting Notes:This is our oldest oil, with which my grandfather started his business more than 60 years ago. It is also the oil for which we are most known and recognized. Moraiolo, Frantoio and Melchiorri olives come from the rocky ground of Umbria along the foothills extending from Spoleto to Assisi. Intense, fruity and full-bodied, the oil features the fragrances and flavors of the enchanting land of Umbria.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
ItalyHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyDOP CertifiedHistorical Competition Archive
Monini• Italy (Umbria DOP)

Olio extra vergine d'oliva DOP Umbria

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Sold at 3 stores (Amazon, Walmart, Wegmans)
Available Stores:AmazonWalmartWegmans
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Borgiona
Great BuyCOOC Seal CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Nemechek Gold• United States (California)

Nemechek Gold Olio Medico

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
United States
Inspect Record
Great BuyCOOC Seal CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganicHistorical Competition Archive
Nemechek Gold• United States (California)

Nemechek Gold Olio Organico

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
United States
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldIGP CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Olio Iolanda Nocellara del Belice• Italy (Sicilia IGP)

Olio Iolanda Nocellara del Belice

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Nocellara del Belice
Oleic Acid %
73.8% (O:L 8.29)
Linoleic %
8.9%
Thermal Score
85/100
ItalyHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganicHistorical Competition Archive
Olio Reserva• Italy (Umbria DOP)

Olio Reserva (Domenica Fiore)

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100

Tasting Notes:Olio Reserva is a certified organic EVOO, and DOP Umbria blend of Leccino, Frantoio and Moraiolo olives that are harvested by hand. The oil is made within four hours of the olives coming off the tree. The result is a golden green oil, robust and full bodied that is clearly from central Italy. Reserva is nitrogen sealed in 18/10 stainless steel bottles to preserve freshness.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
ItalyHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldPGI CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganicHistorical Competition Archive
Oliorama Exclusive Bio PGI Olympia• Greece (Olympia PGI)

Oliorama Exclusive Bio PGI Olympia - Oliorama & Co

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA85/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Koroneiki
Oleic Acid %
76.2% (O:L 9.65)
Linoleic %
7.9%
Thermal Score
92/100
GreeceHarvest: 2018
Inspect Record
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldPGI CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
Oliorama Exclusive PGI Olympia• Greece (Olympia PGI)

Oliorama Exclusive PGI Olympia - Oliorama & Co

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA81/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Koroneiki
Oleic Acid %
76.2% (O:L 9.65)
Linoleic %
7.9%
Thermal Score
92/100
GreeceHarvest: 2022
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$66.67/L
McEvoy Ranch• United States (California (Petaluma))

Organic Olio Nuovo Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 85% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$50.00 (750 mL · $66.67/L) at McEvoy Ranch DirectMcEvoy Ranch Direct
Verified 2026-11-04
Cultivar: Not Listed Online (Check Bottle)
United StatesDark GlassHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Showing 1–13 of 13 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next