Verified Supermarket & Direct-to-Consumer Olive Oils

OLIVE OIL BOTTLE DATABASE

Compare 177 extra virgin olive oils sold across major US grocery stores and direct from estate producers—rated for origin transparency, olive variety chemistry, harvest freshness, and retail value.

7
Active Bottles Shown
84
Cultivar Disclosed
2
Lab Tested
Filter by Store or Online Retailer
Include Specialty & Competition Archive (496)OFF
Reset
Showing 1–7 of 7 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next
Top PickDOP CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$35.99/L
Bono• Italy (Sicily (Val di Mazara DOP))

Olive Oil, Organic, Extra Virgin, Sicilian

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Wegmans
$17.99 (500 mL · $35.99/L) at WegmansWegmans
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Biancolilla, Cerasuola, Nocellara del BeliceHigh
Oleic Acid %
73.8% (O:L 8.29)
Linoleic %
8.9%
Thermal Score
85/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickDOP CertifiedMedium Intensity
$33.99/L
Bono• Italy (Sicily (Val di Mazara DOP))

Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Wegmans
$16.99 (500 mL · $33.99/L) at WegmansWegmans
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Biancolilla, Cerasuola, Nocellara del BeliceHigh
Oleic Acid %
73.8% (O:L 8.29)
Linoleic %
8.9%
Thermal Score
85/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickRobust Intensity
$19.89/L
Partanna• Italy (Sicily (Val di Mazara))

Everyday Medium Sicilian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+96/100
Sold at 2 stores (Direct Online, Walmart)
Available Stores:Direct OnlineWalmart
$15.00 (754 mL · $19.89/L) at WalmartWalmart
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:Experience the essence of Sicily with Partanna Medium Extra Virgin Olive Oil, crafted from a carefully balanced blend of Cerasuola and Nocellara olives. Harvested in the rolling groves of Trapani, Sicily, these olives are hand-picked at the peak of ripeness each fall and cold-pressed within hours to preserve their extraordinary freshness and flavor.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
CerasuolaHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.2% (O:L 9.06)
Linoleic %
8.3%
Thermal Score
90/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyTin Can
Inspect Record
Top PickRobust IntensityOrganic
$83.90/L
Bona Furtuna• Italy (Sicily)

Forte Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+95/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$41.95 (500 mL · $83.90/L) at Bona Furtuna DirectBona Furtuna Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:Meet our boldest extra virgin olive oil. Forte Blend is cold extracted from a mix of Sicilian heirloom olives grown throughout our olive grove at La Furtuna Estate. This mix includes the Cerasuola variety, small but unmistakably robust, giving our Forte Blend its distinctively powerful flavor perfect to stand up to rich grilled dishes and hearty stews.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
CerasuolaHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.2% (O:L 9.06)
Linoleic %
8.3%
Thermal Score
90/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Great BuyMedium Intensity
$36.00/L
Frankies 457• Italy (Sicily)

Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA90/100
Available Stores:Whole Foods
$35.99 (1000 mL · $36.00/L) at Whole FoodsWhole Foods
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Nocellara del Belice, Biancolilla, CerasuolaHigh
Oleic Acid %
72.5% (O:L 7.63)
Linoleic %
9.5%
Thermal Score
83/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Great BuyMedium IntensityOrganic
$40.01/L
Frankies 457• Italy (Sicily)

Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA88/100
Available Stores:Whole Foods
$39.99 (1000 mL · $40.01/L) at Whole FoodsWhole Foods
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Nocellara del Belice, Biancolilla, CerasuolaHigh
Oleic Acid %
72.5% (O:L 7.63)
Linoleic %
9.5%
Thermal Score
83/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Great BuyMedium Intensity
$21.99/L
Trader Joe's• Italy (Sicily)

Sicilian Selezione Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 75% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA85/100
Available Stores:Trader Joe's
$10.99 (500 mL · $21.99/L) at Trader Joe'sTrader Joe's
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Biancolilla, Nocellara del Belice, CerasuolaHigh
Oleic Acid %
73.8% (O:L 8.29)
Linoleic %
8.9%
Thermal Score
85/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
ItalyDark Glass
Inspect Record
Showing 1–7 of 7 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next