Verified Supermarket & Direct-to-Consumer Olive Oils

OLIVE OIL BOTTLE DATABASE

Compare 177 extra virgin olive oils sold across major US grocery stores and direct from estate producers—rated for origin transparency, olive variety chemistry, harvest freshness, and retail value.

13
Total Bottles Shown
441
Cultivar Disclosed
2
Lab Tested
Filter by Store or Online Retailer
Include Specialty & Competition Archive (496)ON
Reset
Showing 1–13 of 13 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next
Great BuyNYIOOC GoldPDO CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganicHistorical Competition Archive
Est. TrustA89/100
Sold at 2 stores (Amazon, Whole Foods)
Available Stores:AmazonWhole Foods

Tasting Notes:Our Organic PDO Single Estate olive oil is crafted in the heart of the Messara Valley in Crete, where olives represent a cherished tradition. This oil features a luxurious, fruity aroma complemented by a distinct peppery note with medium pungency, enriched with hints of herbs and spices.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Koroneiki
Oleic Acid %
76.2% (O:L 9.65)
Linoleic %
7.9%
Thermal Score
92/100
GreeceHarvest: 2026
Inspect Record
Great BuyCOOC Seal CertifiedMedium IntensityHistorical Competition Archive
The Napa Valley Reserve• United States (California)

The Napa Valley Reserve Members Blend

Data Confidence: 65% (Med Confidence)
Est. TrustA89/100
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
United States
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedRobust Intensity
$19.95/L
Cobram Estate• United States (California (Sacramento Valley))

100% California Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Sold at 2 stores (Wegmans, Whole Foods)
Available Stores:WegmansWhole Foods
$14.99 (751 mL · $19.95/L) at WegmansWegmans
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina, Arbosana, CoratinaHigh
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium Intensity
$33.07/L
Cobram Estate• United States (California (Sacramento Valley))

100% California Select Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Walmart
$12.42 (376 mL · $33.07/L) at WalmartWalmart
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina, Arbosana, CoratinaHigh
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedSmooth / Mild Intensity
$38.98/L
Cobram Estate• United States (California (Sacramento Valley))

100% California Mild Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Walmart
$14.64 (376 mL · $38.98/L) at WalmartWalmart
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina, Arbosana, CoratinaHigh
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium Intensity
$20.00/L
Cobram Estate• United States (California (Sacramento Valley))

100% California Classic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Sold at 3 stores (Walmart, Wegmans, Whole Foods)
Available Stores:WalmartWegmansWhole Foods
$19.99 (1000 mL · $20.00/L) at WegmansWegmans
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina, Arbosana, CoratinaHigh
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium Intensity
$49.00/L
Corto Olive Co• United States (California (San Joaquin Valley))

TRULY® Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$24.50 (500 mL · $49.00/L) at Corto Olive Co DirectCorto Olive Co Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:Named TRULY ® because it’s the real deal — full-bodied and dynamic with bright floral notes you could only get from fresh-squeezed juice. Made from California-grown olives harvested at their peak freshness, our ultra fresh, Extra Virgin Olive Oil is cold-extracted and packaged upon order so it tastes just as fresh when it reaches your kitchen.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina, Arbosana, KoroneikiHigh
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickPDO CertifiedMedium IntensityOrganic
$119.26/L
Ellora Farms• Greece (Crete PDO (Kolymvari / Messara))

Organic and PDO Single Estate Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Messara Valley Greece

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$59.95 (503 mL · $119.26/L) at Ellora Farms DirectEllora Farms Direct
Verified 2026-11-04
Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
KoroneikiHigh
Oleic Acid %
76.2% (O:L 9.65)
Linoleic %
7.9%
Thermal Score
92/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
GreeceDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedMedium Intensity
$69.33/L
Frantoio Grove• United States (California (Santa Clara Valley))

Verdant EVOO

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$26.00 (375 mL · $69.33/L) at Frantoio Grove DirectFrantoio Grove Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:A classic Picual from Jaén, Spain, selected for the greener side of olive oil. Tomato leaf and fresh-cut grass lead the aroma, followed by green tomato, bell pepper, lettuce and bitter endive. Black pepper, warm spice and mint carry through the finish. It is bright and distinctly green without becoming punishingly bitter or throat-catching.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
PicualHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedSmooth / Mild Intensity
$104.00/L
Ojai Olive Oil• United States (California (Ojai Valley))

Provençale Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$26.00 (250 mL · $104.00/L) at Ojai Olive Oil DirectOjai Olive Oil Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:This year’s Provençale extra virgin olive oil is crafted from a blend of Columella, Nocellara del Belice, Picholene, Arbosana & Cailletier olives. These olive varietals tend to produce very mild, smooth & fruity olive oils, and are harvested & milled late in the season to maximize the sweet and buttery notes of the fruit.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbosana, Cailletier, Nocellara del BeliceHigh
Oleic Acid %
72.1% (O:L 7.36)
Linoleic %
9.8%
Thermal Score
81/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedSmooth / Mild IntensityOrganic
$101.33/L
Ojai Olive Oil• United States (California (Ojai Valley))

Signature Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 85% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+100/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$38.00 (375 mL · $101.33/L) at Ojai Olive Oil DirectOjai Olive Oil Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:This year’s Signature extra virgin olive oil is a special mono-varietal bottling of oil only from Columella olives. Columella olives tend to produce a particularly buttery, smooth, mild, & fruity olive oil. This year’s harvest of these olives was picked and milled very late in the season to maximize the sweet & subtle notes of the fruit.

Cultivar: Not Listed Online (Check Bottle)
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedRobust Intensity
$90.67/L
Ojai Olive Oil• United States (California (Ojai Valley))

Tuscan Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+95/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$34.00 (375 mL · $90.67/L) at Ojai Olive Oil DirectOjai Olive Oil Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:This year’s Tuscan extra virgin olive oil is crafted from a blend of primarily Frantoio, Leccino, Pendolino, Picual & Koroneiki olives. These olive varietals tend to produce characteristically grassy, peppery & fruity olive oils, and are harvested & milled early in the season to maximize the green and vibrant notes of the fruit.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Frantoio, Koroneiki, LeccinoHigh
Oleic Acid %
75.8% (O:L 9.36)
Linoleic %
8.1%
Thermal Score
89/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Top PickCOOC CertifiedRobust Intensity
$104.00/L
Ojai Olive Oil• United States (California (Ojai Valley))

Andalucian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Data Confidence: 100% (High Confidence)
Est. TrustA+95/100
Available Stores:Direct Online
$26.00 (250 mL · $104.00/L) at Ojai Olive Oil DirectOjai Olive Oil Direct
Verified 2026-11-04

Tasting Notes:This year’s Andalucian extra virgin olive oil is crafted from a blend of Lechin de Sevilla, Coratina, Hojiblanca, Koroneiki, Arbequina & Picual olives. These olive varietals tend to produce very strong, peppery and robust olive oils, and are harvested & milled in the middle in the season to balance the sharper and softer notes of the fruit.

Olive Variety (Cultivar) Profile
Arbequina, Coratina, HojiblancaHigh
Oleic Acid %
66.5% (O:L 5.2)
Linoleic %
12.8%
Thermal Score
71/100
Ref Polyphenols
300 mg/kg
United StatesDark Glass
Inspect Record
Showing 1–13 of 13 commercial bottles • Page 1 of 1
Prev1Next